Senedd Home
Oggy Bloggy Ogwr
State of Wales
Monday, October 5, 2026
  • About & Contact
    • About State of Wales
    • Comments Policy
    • Complaints Policy
    • Contact
    • Disclaimer
  • Elections Centre
  • The Independence Index
    • The Independence Index (Full)
    • Foreign Policy
      • Relations with the former UK & Ireland
      • Relations with Europe
      • Foreign Policy (General)
      • International Organisations & Law
      • Overseas Aid
    • Defence
      • Defence Policy
      • NATO
      • Armed Forces
      • National Security
      • Civil Defence
    • Rules & Regulations
      • Safety & Standards
      • Intellectual Property
    • Economics & Money
      • Business & Economy
      • Currency
      • Tax & Spending
      • Transport & Infrastructure
    • Society
      • Communities & Housing
      • Culture & Sport
      • Education
      • Health
      • Media & Communications
      • Science & Technology
    • The State
      • Environment & Natural Resources
      • Justice
      • Local Government
  • Support & Donate
No Result
View All Result
  • About & Contact
    • About State of Wales
    • Comments Policy
    • Complaints Policy
    • Contact
    • Disclaimer
  • Elections Centre
  • The Independence Index
    • The Independence Index (Full)
    • Foreign Policy
      • Relations with the former UK & Ireland
      • Relations with Europe
      • Foreign Policy (General)
      • International Organisations & Law
      • Overseas Aid
    • Defence
      • Defence Policy
      • NATO
      • Armed Forces
      • National Security
      • Civil Defence
    • Rules & Regulations
      • Safety & Standards
      • Intellectual Property
    • Economics & Money
      • Business & Economy
      • Currency
      • Tax & Spending
      • Transport & Infrastructure
    • Society
      • Communities & Housing
      • Culture & Sport
      • Education
      • Health
      • Media & Communications
      • Science & Technology
    • The State
      • Environment & Natural Resources
      • Justice
      • Local Government
  • Support & Donate
No Result
View All Result
State of Wales
No Result
View All Result
Home Feature Pieces

Chinny Reckon: Is Wales “a republican heartland?”

The claim has been made in recent press reports, but does it actually stand up to any scrutiny?

Owen Donovan by Owen Donovan
May 9, 2023
in Feature Pieces
Chinny Reckon: Is Wales “a republican heartland?”
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on RedditShare on BlueskyShare by email

Now that the world’s most expensive game of musical chairs is out of the way, it’s worth picking up on a report that did the rounds before Chuckles’ coronation.

YouGov polling on attitudes towards the monarchy was reported as showing that Wales is – to quote The i – a “republican heartland”.

However much I’d like to believe that, it didn’t quite ring true. So I decided to look at it myself, my chin growing ever itchier.

A Welsh Constitution IV (b): Head of State – Republic
Constitution

A Welsh Constitution IV (b): Head of State – Republic

May 13, 2020
A Welsh Constitution IV (a): Head of State – Constitutional Monarchy
Constitution

A Welsh Constitution IV (a): Head of State – Constitutional Monarchy

May 11, 2020
IndyWales & The Crown Estate
Environment & Natural Resources

IndyWales & The Crown Estate

February 7, 2022

3. Conclusion: Apathy needs to reign?

  • 1. What are the polling trends?
  • 2. What does this say about Wales’ relationship with the monarchy?
  • 3. Conclusion: Apathy needs to reign?
Previous
Next

Much like those who support Welsh independence, republicans are a sizable minority whose views have gone mainstream – but a minority they remain and Wales most certainly isn’t a republican heartland. I don’t see how it could be interpreted as such for the time being.

There’s the outside chance that a big scandal could bring the whole thing down, or the UK might elect a republican government at some point. The more likely scenario is a gradual deflation of support and what might clinch it in the end is apathy.

No matter how hard the mainstream British media might try, they can’t make you care about the institution.

The House of Windsor has a strong survival instinct that republicans may be under-estimating, but not caring is the monarchy’s kryptonite. To paraphrase the late Queen, the monarchy “has to be seen to be believed”. They have to come to you. The moment they’re not seen, not available or nobody cares about them anymore is the moment they’re in trouble.

That said, there’s a bit of a “one last push” trope amongst sections of the Welsh political scene where they point to one poll and think momentum is with them, but they ignore the longer-term trend, which may not have changed very much in a long time. Case in point.

3. Conclusion: Apathy needs to reign?

  • 1. What are the polling trends?
  • 2. What does this say about Wales’ relationship with the monarchy?
  • 3. Conclusion: Apathy needs to reign?
Previous
Next
Tags: ConstitutionEnglandHead of StateScotlandSocial AttitudesSocial MediaThe Monarchy
Previous Post

IndyWales & The Football Exiles

Next Post

Wales on the Move I: Transport & Devolution – Who does what?

Owen Donovan

Owen Donovan

Archive

Categories

Copyright

Creative Commons Licence

State of Wales by Owen Donovan is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Subscribe by Email

Search

No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
  • Go To Senedd Home
  • Go To Oggy Bloggy Ogwr
  • About & Contact
    • About State of Wales
    • Comments Policy
    • Complaints Policy
    • Contact & Subscribe by Email
    • Disclaimer
  • Features
    • After the UK
    • Chinny Reckon
    • Devil’s Advocate
    • How Wales Works
    • Road to Brexit
  • The Independence Index
    • The Independence Index (full)
    • Economics & Money
      • Business & Economy
      • Currency
      • Tax & Spending
      • Transport & Infrastructure
    • Society
      • Communities & Housing
      • Culture & Sport
      • Education
      • Health
      • Media & Communications
      • Science & Technology
    • The State
      • Environment & Natural Resources
      • Justice
      • Local Government
  • Elections Centre
  • Wales FAQ
    • How is Wales funded?
    • How are laws in Wales made?
  • Support & Donate