Although hardly anyone bothered to vote, towards the end of 2020 the justice system was selected on Twitter as the next in-depth topic for the Independence Index.
Instead of posting it all in one go, I’ve decided to split it into four “themes” which will be posted gradually between now and spring 2022 (if the independence “movement” still exists by then).
The first theme – a look at the legal system itself – is probably the most boring/technically complicated one, so I decided to get it out of the way first.
This includes legal administration and structure, how laws are made and how the law is balanced with, and complements, the constitution and civil rights.
As usual, I thought I’d kick things off with a look at where we’re at now.
While the Senedd can create new criminal offences and set punishments in devolved policy areas (i.e. fines for smoking in public or fly-tipping), civil and criminal justice remains a reserved matter.
Wales has no powers over policing, the courts, probation services or prisons and the Senedd couldn’t, for example, pass a law on murder, sexual assault or procedures for small claims.
The UK Government and UK Parliament retain control over these areas in England and Wales, with executive responsibility split between directly-elected Police & Crime Commissioners, the UK Home Office and the UK Ministry of Justice.
There’s a clear disconnect between the powers necessary to maintain law and order, the social policy powers needed to reduce and control crime (both of which are mainly controlled at the UK level), and the lower level social policy powers needed to support the criminal justice system and the police (controlled mainly at the Welsh level).
This results in very complicated arrangements:
Wales is also perhaps unique in the world in being able to make its own laws without having its own legal jurisdiction. All laws and regulations made by the Senedd are deemed to be part of English (and Welsh) law even if they apply solely in Wales.
One argument in favour of retaining “England and Wales” as a legal jurisdiction is that criminal law and the criminal justice system isn’t devolved and is essentially the same as England. Therefore, there’s no need for Wales to be a distinct legal jurisdiction like Scotland and Northern Ireland. There haven’t been any barriers to the operation of Welsh law by sharing a legal jurisdiction.
Those in favour of a Welsh legal jurisdiction argue that Welsh law has significantly diverged from England in many cases (particularly in housing, planning and environmental law) and the time has now come for that to be properly recognised to avoid any confusion.
The debate over the creation of a Welsh legal jurisdiction and the devolution of the justice system has been on-off for the best part of 15 years, having been seen as a means of putting Wales on an equal footing with Scotland and Northern Ireland within the UK.
In 2019, the Thomas Commission – chaired by former Lord Chief Justice, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd – reported back on their two-year-long review of the justice system in Wales.

Within weeks of the report’s publication the First Minister, Mark Drakeford, announced that a Cabinet committee would be established to take the recommendations forward.
Several academic reports published since the Thomas Commission have highlighted serious failures in the prison system in Wales, while proposals by the UK Government for new prisons and alike have been met with a backlash.
Labour’s 2021 manifesto contained a commitment to continue to explore the devolution of policing and justice. However, to very little fanfare at the start of 2020 the Thomas Commission recommendations were rejected outright by the UK Government.



















