Following last week’s local elections, here’s a more detailed look at what happened nationally and what each of the parties/groups can take from the results.
Labour

It was a very good election for Labour. Naturally, they’re going to have a much higher starting point and very little wriggle room to go beyond that, but some of their gains were impressive.
The standout results were in Rhondda Cynon Taf (winning almost 80% of the seats) and Cardiff where – as expected – Labour secured big increases to their majorities. They also comfortably retained control of Caerphilly, Newport and Torfaen, while securing a major swing in their favour in Blaenau Gwent to take overall control.
It looks as though Labour will lead new administrations in Denbighshire, Vale of Glamorgan and (against all expectations and one of the best performances of the election) Monmouthshire. Flintshire seems more touch and go.
Despite this overall positive set of election results, Labour didn’t have it all their own way and the results aren’t that exceptional compared to past local elections.
Labour fell short of taking outright control of Merthyr Tydfil despite expectations that they could win a majority. A minority administration is doable, but a coalition with one of the Independent groups would make more sense. Similarly, they perhaps didn’t perform as well as expected in Wrexham where the Independent and Tory vote held up (and Plaid Cymru performed strongly).
The result in Bridgend was closer run than people think. Labour lost two Cabinet Members and didn’t perform well in the new Bridgend town wards. The result largely came down to a Tory vote collapse in the politically crucial suburb of Brackla. It’s a win and they’ll take it, but it’s not convincing and is perhaps a pyrrhic victory because the opposition is mainly made up of very vocal Independents who could cause Labour far more problems than the Tories ever have.
Losing overall control over Neath Port Talbot is almost as bad as the Conservatives losing Monmouthshire – but it won’t get the same attention. The Labour vote has been slipping back there for a while. Local residents would know more about why it happened than I do.
As is seemingly the tradition in Welsh local elections of defenestrating council leaders, the highest-profile casualty was the former Labour leader of Caerphilly Council, Philippa Marsden, who lost her seat due to a reported local controversy over a recycling centre.
Independents

Independents remain the second largest “group” in Welsh local government and continue to prove stubbornly difficult for the mainstream political parties to shift.
How and why they performed well will be largely down to local factors than any national picture. Generally speaking, Independents performed better in local authorities where they were in opposition (with exceptions like Pembrokeshire, Conwy and the Vale of Glamorgan).
It may be the case that people are happy to vote for a local community champion not tied to the mucky business of party politics in order to make some noise on behalf of their ward, but perhaps less likely to vote them in to run a council by themselves when times are tough.
Independents also seem to have benefited from a large number of uncontested seats, particularly in Pembrokeshire and Gwynedd.
Independent candidates performed well or very well in some local authorities (Bridgend, Neath Port Talbot, Flintshire) and didn’t do as badly as expected in Gwynedd and Merthyr Tydfil. There were only two stand out poor performances in Powys and Blaenau Gwent, which may have been partly down to the big reduction in councillors, the sitting administration being unpopular/making unpopular decisions and/or boundary changes.
Plaid Cymru

Despite a large amount of red on the map, it was a good election for Plaid Cymru.
I’ve long been critical of the way Plaid Cymru manufactures victories out of underperformances, but they did about as well as can be expected given that they usually get squeezed out when elections are portrayed as “Labour vs Tories”. Quite a few of their losses are probably down to boundary changes too rather than straight-up defeats; Pauline Jarman, for example, may have retained her seat in Mountain Ash under the old boundaries and not had to go up against RCT’s Leader.
They increased the number of councils under their outright control by a greater margin than Labour.
OK, they only had to win about a half dozen seats to do so compared to 2017, but they managed to do something no other party has done before and win a majority on Carmarthenshire Council and be the first mainstream political party to win a majority on Anglesey.
There were standout performances in local authorities outside of Plaid’s heartland too, particularly Wrexham and Vale of Glamorgan. In both cases, for several years the local Plaid branches have done a lot of grassroots campaigning at the county and town/community council levels. This is a far better approach than putting up paper candidates and taking selfies.
Plaid managed to keep most of what they had in Caerphilly (and nominally increased their proportion of seats due to the cut in the number of councillors) and look set to potentially form part of ruling coalitions in Neath Port Talbot (where they did well in Neath and the Swansea Valley) and possibly Denbighshire. Yes, they did poorly in Rhondda Cynon Taf – by seat numbers their worse performance since the authority was established. However, even though a poor performance was anticipated it could’ve been even worse (in my opinion).
The other big disappointment (if you can call it such) is arguably the much-hyped Common Ground Alliance with the Greens in Cardiff. As mentioned earlier, in terms of the vote share they didn’t do that badly (17% of total votes cast), but they were never going to directly compete with Labour, while the Lib Dem vote held up better than expected.
Additionally, there are several local authorities where Plaid Cymru “The Party of Wales” has zero (or very little) representation in local government. They’re still over-reliant on winning seats in their Fro Gymraeg heartland and that’s padded their overall results a little bit; at least Labour can say they have councillors everywhere.
Conservatives

There’s little that can be added to what’s already been said. While they still just about retain a three-figure number of councillors, the Conservatives have been delivered quite a firm kick to the arse.
They’ve lost about 40% of their councillors in Wales and it’s not only the results in the so-called “Red Wall” areas (the northeast and Bridgend) you need to look at. What ought to be ringing alarm bells for the Tories is how badly they did in the Welsh equivalent of the English “shire counties” (particularly Monmouthshire, Vale of Glamorgan and Powys).
Managing to get as many candidates as they did to stand isn’t a small achievement, but paper candidates don’t make a party. When political parties in power start doing that you know they’re on the way down.
If elected, these last-minute “stick a name on the ballot” candidates don’t take the role seriously enough, don’t do any grassroots campaigning outside of election periods and don’t turn up to meetings. They just take the allowance, prioritise the day job and keep schtum – as some of Bridgend’s 2017 intake of Tory councillors did.
There are very few results you can point to and say are “good”. Maybe the fact they retain the same proportion of seats in Pembrokeshire and didn’t get completely wiped out in some councils. They just about remain the largest opposition group on Cardiff Council and are still in a position to form ruling coalitions in Conwy, Wrexham and possibly Pembrokeshire.
There’s already been some chatter that the UK party are blaming the loss of Monmouthshire on the council being “compassionate conservatives”. They weren’t evil enough, apparently. They’re becoming a parody of themselves. As an independence supporter, long may it continue. Keep up the good work!
Lib Dems, Greens & Others
One of the big stories of the election was the long-awaited breakthrough by the Green Party, which won 8 councillors across seven local authorities.
I don’t think they’ll care about the ins and outs as to why they did so well (they still did much better in England but they have to start somewhere), though it could be a mix of good campaigning on the ground by individual candidates, the climate emergency moving more towards the forefront of people’s political agendas or being seen as an acceptable protest vote by disgruntled supporters of other parties. I doubt the lowering of the voting age to 16 will have played that much of a role, but who knows?
The other big story that perhaps isn’t getting much attention is the relative success of the Lib Dems – especially in Powys. They were expected to do well there but it’s safe to say they exceeded expectations and are now in a position to lead the council.
The Lib Dem vote also held up well in Cardiff despite increased opposition from the Common Ground Alliance and they also broke back into a double-figure number of councillors in Swansea – which considering the relative popularity of the Labour council there is no small feat.
The bad news? The Lib Dems have now been wiped out in Bridgend and Monmouthshire and they don’t have any representation in 9 local authorities.
There were two big results for the other minor parties.
Neil McEvoy retained his Fairwater seat in Cardiff for Propel. Technically it’s a gain, but Propel is down two councillors since their mass defection from Plaid Cymru during the last term. The results seem to have been fairly close-run in Fairwater, but Labour had too much on them.
Across Cardiff as a whole, Propel didn’t do well and their performance is padded by the votes in Fairwater. They finished behind the Conservatives and the Common Ground Alliance in many wards and in some cases Propel candidates were stuck on double-figure vote totals.
The leader of the (considered to be right-wing by many) Welsh nationalist party, Gwlad – Gwyn Wigley Evans – won the Llanrhystyd seat in Ceredigion to become their first elected county councillor in Wales. Gwlad also picked up a few seats at town and community council level in Rhondda Cynon Taf.

