Senedd Home
Oggy Bloggy Ogwr
State of Wales
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
  • About & Contact
    • About State of Wales
    • Comments Policy
    • Complaints Policy
    • Contact
    • Disclaimer
  • Elections Centre
  • The Independence Index
    • The Independence Index (Full)
    • Foreign Policy
      • Relations with the former UK & Ireland
      • Relations with Europe
      • Foreign Policy (General)
      • International Organisations & Law
      • Overseas Aid
    • Defence
      • Defence Policy
      • NATO
      • Armed Forces
      • National Security
      • Civil Defence
    • Rules & Regulations
      • Safety & Standards
      • Intellectual Property
    • Economics & Money
      • Business & Economy
      • Currency
      • Tax & Spending
      • Transport & Infrastructure
    • Society
      • Communities & Housing
      • Culture & Sport
      • Education
      • Health
      • Media & Communications
      • Science & Technology
    • The State
      • Environment & Natural Resources
      • Justice
      • Local Government
  • Support & Donate
No Result
View All Result
  • About & Contact
    • About State of Wales
    • Comments Policy
    • Complaints Policy
    • Contact
    • Disclaimer
  • Elections Centre
  • The Independence Index
    • The Independence Index (Full)
    • Foreign Policy
      • Relations with the former UK & Ireland
      • Relations with Europe
      • Foreign Policy (General)
      • International Organisations & Law
      • Overseas Aid
    • Defence
      • Defence Policy
      • NATO
      • Armed Forces
      • National Security
      • Civil Defence
    • Rules & Regulations
      • Safety & Standards
      • Intellectual Property
    • Economics & Money
      • Business & Economy
      • Currency
      • Tax & Spending
      • Transport & Infrastructure
    • Society
      • Communities & Housing
      • Culture & Sport
      • Education
      • Health
      • Media & Communications
      • Science & Technology
    • The State
      • Environment & Natural Resources
      • Justice
      • Local Government
  • Support & Donate
No Result
View All Result
State of Wales
No Result
View All Result
Home Health

IndyWales & Alcohol

How can we properly balance the good things and bad things about booze?

Owen Donovan by Owen Donovan
December 2, 2024
in Health, Independence: Health
IndyWales & Alcohol
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on RedditShare on BlueskyShare by email

Does Wales have a drinking problem? If so, what can be done about it? Is the problem fixing itself?

Having first looked at alcohol policy and independence 10 years ago – and as a neat little follow-up on this summer’s drugs policy series – it’s time for an update.

Given the central role alcohol plays in our cultural and social lives – as well as our hospitality industry – how an independent Wales could approach alcohol policy isn’t as superficial as it seems.

2. What issues need to be addressed?

  • 1. Wales’ relationship with alcohol
  • 2. What issues need to be addressed?
  • 3. How do other countries approach alcohol policy?
  • 4. What alcohol policies could an IndyWales look at again?
Previous
Next
A person holding a bottle of spirits.
Minimum unit pricing in Wales has a “sunset clause” due to kick in just before the 2026 Senedd election. Will we follow Scotland in raising the minimum price, or will the policy be scrapped after accusations that it’s been ineffective? (Pic: Senedd Research Service, Crown copyright)

 

How, when and why we start drinking

Nobody should start drinking, or continue drinking, “to get drunk”.

Most of the people reading this will have done it at least once – and a one-off every now and again perhaps isn’t so bad. Though drinking alcohol should be something that’s eased into gradually.

A particularly Welsh example would be well-publicised issues with drunkenness at Welsh rugby internationals. The WRU has taken steps to address this by creating alcohol-free zones, but it’s clear that there’s some friction between the “day trippers” (who might have a corporate ticket) and people who are genuinely there to watch the game.

If positive associations with alcohol are there from an early age, then you would hope a more moderate attitude would continue into adulthood. Cultures where alcohol is almost always only served with a meal – Greece, Italy etc. – don’t have much of a binge-drinking culture.

Alcohol’s impact on the emergency services

The statistics suggest that the number of people hospitalised because of alcohol is falling – but that doesn’t mean night-time problems with drunkenness have gone away.

It may be anecdotal, but there’s a good chance that a lot of the emergency services work at weekends is taken up with alcohol-related incidents – whether it’s a drunken fight in a queue outside a takeaway or someone who’s passed out and needs an ambulance. This will all come at a cost – both financially and in terms of the stress put on frontline staff.

There are different approaches to this. The softer approach includes things like street pastors, as well as “drunk tanks” where people can sober up without needing to be taken into police custody.

Harder measures include pressuring councils to withdraw or deny licenses to problem venues. There’s also the on-off debate on whether people turning up to A&E departments with alcohol-related injuries should be charged a fee.

The future of minimum unit pricing

As mentioned earlier, a “sunset clause” in the Minimum Alcohol Pricing Act 2018 means the Senedd will review minimum pricing before March 2026.

The evidence to date suggests minimum alcohol pricing hasn’t had much of an effect. As of 20229, according to the Senedd Research Service alcohol sales dropped following the introduction of minimum pricing but alcohol-related deaths have increased. Any drop in alcohol consumption was put down to the Covid-19 pandemic than minimum pricing.

The Conservatives – who opposed the policy when it was introduced – described minimum pricing as a failure in 2023.

My expectation is the Welsh Government are unlikely to drop the policy because that would be an admission of failure. The debate (when the policy is up for review) will more likely be over whether the existing 50p-per-unit limit should be increased (as happened in Scotland).

The future of the pub

As noted earlier, the decline of local pubs is happening faster in Wales than in England.

You’ll get different answers from different people as to why.

Some people have long blamed public smoking bans. The more recent decline has been blamed on changes to business rates and the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic. There’s also competition on price with supermarkets, as well as a shift towards drinking at home over drinking at a pub or club.

While the decline of pubs has an obvious impact on local economies, the social element might get overlooked (much like local sports clubs). In some smaller communities, the local pub might be the only communal space. The chapel/church isn’t relevant to most people anymore and many communities may have previously lost libraries, social clubs and community centres.

Despite this, pubs have noticeably improved their offer in some areas over the last few decades.

The food is often better, the drink choices are better than they used to be, you can usually do things other than drink and (more often than not) they seem cleaner and more welcoming.

9. Senedd Research (28th October 2022). “Wales’ drinking habits: how much has changed since minimum pricing for alcohol?”. Available at: https://research.senedd.wales/research-articles/wales-drinking-habits-how-much-has-changed-since-minimum-pricing-for-alcohol/

2. What issues need to be addressed?

  • 1. Wales’ relationship with alcohol
  • 2. What issues need to be addressed?
  • 3. How do other countries approach alcohol policy?
  • 4. What alcohol policies could an IndyWales look at again?
Previous
Next
Tags: DenmarkDevolutionDrugsFood & Drink IndustryHospitality IndustryIrelandLicensingLocal GovernmentMen's IssuesNew ZealandNHSPolicingPublic HealthScotlandSeneddSwitzerlandTaxWelsh Law
Previous Post

Radical Wales: Liquid Democracy

Next Post

IndyWales, Smoking & Vaping

Owen Donovan

Owen Donovan

Archive

Categories

Copyright

Creative Commons Licence

State of Wales by Owen Donovan is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Subscribe by Email

Search

No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
  • Go To Senedd Home
  • Go To Oggy Bloggy Ogwr
  • About & Contact
    • About State of Wales
    • Comments Policy
    • Complaints Policy
    • Contact & Subscribe by Email
    • Disclaimer
  • Features
    • After the UK
    • Chinny Reckon
    • Devil’s Advocate
    • How Wales Works
    • Road to Brexit
  • The Independence Index
    • The Independence Index (full)
    • Economics & Money
      • Business & Economy
      • Currency
      • Tax & Spending
      • Transport & Infrastructure
    • Society
      • Communities & Housing
      • Culture & Sport
      • Education
      • Health
      • Media & Communications
      • Science & Technology
    • The State
      • Environment & Natural Resources
      • Justice
      • Local Government
  • Elections Centre
  • Wales FAQ
    • How is Wales funded?
    • How are laws in Wales made?
  • Support & Donate