Does Wales have a drinking problem? If so, what can be done about it? Is the problem fixing itself?
Having first looked at alcohol policy and independence 10 years ago – and as a neat little follow-up on this summer’s drugs policy series – it’s time for an update.
Given the central role alcohol plays in our cultural and social lives – as well as our hospitality industry – how an independent Wales could approach alcohol policy isn’t as superficial as it seems.

Changes to the drinking age
There are a few choices regarding legal purchase and drinking age:
- No change – Maintain the current blanket 18 age limit to buy alcohol to be consumed on its own, with much lower age limits for drinking in private.
- Lower the drinking age (Luxembourg, Georgia) – As above, but with the legal age to buy alcohol lowered from 18 to 16.
- Teutonic age policy (Germany, Austria, Switzerland, Denmark) –Â Keep the 18 age limit to buy distilled alcohol (spirits) alongside an age limit of 16 age for non-distilled alcohol (beer, wine, cider).
While there’s some ambiguity at the moment, under-18s could be allowed to buy low and zero-alcoholic drinks on licenced premises without being asked for ID.
Public drinking laws
Local authorities already have the power to create designated areas where drinking in public/outdoors is forbidden. There’s probably no reason to change this as designated areas are usually only established where there’s a proven problem with anti-social behaviour.
Sales restrictions & state alcohol monopoly
As noted earlier, while a complete ban on alcohol sales in supermarkets is impractical, there’s nothing wrong – in principle – with restricting the strength of alcohol allowed to be sold there (i.e. to beers and ciders under a certain percentage). So if you wanted something stronger you would either have to buy it at a pub, bar or specialist off-licence.
This would be similar to the policy in the Nordic countries (except Denmark), where you can often only buy alcohol for at-home consumption from state-owned off-licences (known as an alcohol monopoly).
There has already been discussion about banning alcohol discounts (i.e. 2-for-1s, free drinks at public events). This might be easier to implement than any of the above, but could prove unpopular with the public and could be difficult to enforce in some respects (especially within bars and clubs if authorities aren’t on hand to police it).
Licensing reforms
Administratively, the current licensing system works and probably doesn’t need to be tampered with.
There might be an argument for merging premises and club licences to reduce bureaucracy. Licensing committees could also be given greater powers over the length of time they can suspend a licence, or even ban establishments from selling certain categories of drinks (i.e. spirits and cocktails).
The police may be able to argue in favour of scrapping 24-hour licensing (introduced in 2005) if it’s proven to have had a negative impact on alcohol-related crime.
Zero drink-drive limit
There are at least three options:
- Maintain the current drink-driving limit – As noted, the limit in EnglandandWales is higher than the European average.
- Lower it in line with the rest of mainland Europe – 50ml per 100ml of breath. It might result in more drivers being prosecuted for drunk driving (assuming the number of tests carried out doesn’t continue to fall).
- Introduce a zero-drink-drive limit – Drivers who test positive for alcohol but whose readings are below the drink-driving limit (amber light on a breathalyser) could get an on-the-spot fine and 3 licence points (in line with other offences). They wouldn’t have to go through the court system.
Drink-related anti-social behaviour
Opening a debate on whether patients with alcohol-related injuries should be charged for presenting at A&E would potentially lead to unintended consequences. Would all “self-inflicted” (smoking, sports injuries, children playing) healthcare needs result in a charge?
An alternative would be to set up “drunk tanks” in town and city centres at weekends for people who are visibly drunk but who don’t have serious injuries. The issue would be something that appears non-life-threatening becoming so – such as hidden or internal injuries.
Wales could follow Germany’s example and make greater use of police powers to issue on-the-spot fines for nuisance drunken behaviour – essentially fining anyone drunk enough to need to sober up in a police cell or hospital bed.

